Author and year | Methods (country, design) | Participant: sample size, age (mean or mean and SD), female %, primary diagnosis (Dx) | Intervention (type, personnel, setting, brief description of intervention) | Comparison | Follow-up period | Outcomes and tools | Key findings at 6Â months | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Inter* | Cont* | p value | |||||||
a: RCTs | |||||||||
 Interventions by family caregivers | |||||||||
  Chu et al., 2020 | China, RCT | N = 61 Age: intervention 62.84 (9.71), control 66.17 (8.51) Female: intervention 68%, control 53% Dx: stroke, ischemic 59% | Family-caregiver delivered, in-homes after training in hospital Mobility: transfers, walking, stair climbing ADL: grooming, dressing, bathing Continence: bowel and bladder control, toileting | Conventional care, no post-discharge rehabilitation | 6 months | ADLs: BI (0–100) Mean (SD) | 72.6 (21.18) | 61.00 (34.63) | 0.03 |
QOL: EQ-5D Mean (SD) | 1.55 (0.39) | 1.56 (0.54) | 0.91 | ||||||
  Zhou et al., 2019 | China, RCT | N = 244 Age: intervention 64.3, control 66.2 Female: intervention 54%, control 56% Dx: stroke, ischemic 73% | Family-caregiver delivered, in-home after training in hospital Mobility: bed, balance, walking ADL: grooming, dressing, bathing Continence: bowel and bladder control, toileting | Conventional care (no post-discharge rehabilitation) | 6 months | Walking: FAC (0–5) Mean (SD) | 4.6 (1.7) | 5.0 (1.4) | 0.04* |
ADLs: BI (0–100) Mean (SD) | 70.1 (25.5) | 74.1 (23.0) | p = 0.27* | ||||||
QOL: EQ-5D (0–1) Mean (SD) | 0.7 (0.3) | 0.8 (0.3) | 0.15* | ||||||
  Lindley et al., 2017 | India, RCT | N = 1250 Age: intervention 57.5 (12.92), control 58 (14.21) Female: intervention 68%, control 66% Dx: stroke, ischemic 77% | Family-caregiver delivered, in-homes after training in hospital Mobility: limb positioning ADL: task specific activities | Post-discharge care (no therapy to some outpatient therapy sessions) | 6 months | Mobility: EQ-5D-3L (proportion with some or severe deficits) | 237/529 (45%) | 228/510 (45%) | 0.32 |
ADLs: BI (0–100) Mean (SD) | 82.1 (23.09) | 82.6 (23.19) | 0.74 | ||||||
ADLs: NEADL (0–66) Mean (SD) | 31.0 (17.67) | 31.2 (17.52) | 0.86 | ||||||
Selfcare: EQ-5D-3L (proportion with some or severe deficits) | 251/529 (47%) | 230/510 (45%) | 0.75 | ||||||
  Ozdemiret al., 2001 | Turkey, RCT | N = 60 Age: intervention 61.8 (9.2), control 59.1 (5.9) Female: control 30%, intervention 63% Dx: stroke, hemorrhagic 77% | Family-delivered, in-homes after training in hospital Mobility: convenient bed positioning and exercises. Splints, orthoses, and devices were also provided | Therapeutic exercises and neuromuscular facilitation exercises, physical agents | 5 months | Function independence: FIM (18–126), mean change score (SD) | 59.63 (14.19) | 12.30 (13.38) | 0.001 |
 Interventions by community health workers | |||||||||
  Cobbing et al., 2017 | South Africa, RCT | N = 76 Age: intervention 43.4, control 44.7 Female: intervention 76.3%, control 76.3% Dx: HIV | CHWs-delivered in-homes Mobility: aerobic exercises, strength and stretch (upper and lower limbs) and functional exercises (sitting to standing and bridging) and walking | Conventional care, no rehabilitation in the community | 6 months | Mobility: WHODAS (0–4), mean (SD) | 0.18 (0.56) | 0.21 (0.59) |  > 0.05 |
Mobility: RMI (0–15) Mean (SD) | 14.24 (1.50) | 13.82 (2.33) | > 0.05 | ||||||
Walking: 6MWT (distance), mean (SD) | 327.71 (73.61) | 303.29 (92.48) | > 0.05 | ||||||
QOL: WHOQOL (1–5), mean (SD) | 3.62 (0.70) | 3.41 (0.93) | > 0.05 |
Author and year | Methods (country, design) | Participant: sample size, age (mean or mean and SD), female %, primary diagnosis (Dx) | Intervention (type, personnel, setting, brief description of intervention) | Comparison | Follow-up period | Outcomes and tools | Key findings | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CRAT | Cont | p | |||||||
b. Non-RCTs | |||||||||
 Interventions delivered by non-professional community health workers or volunteers | |||||||||
  Ru et al., 2017 | China, non-randomized controlled experiment | N = 365 Age: 61.9 (9.5) Female: 28.9% Dx: stroke, cerebral hemorrhage: 70 (20%) | CRAT by community rehabilitation workers and family caregivers in community centers and patients’ home Mobility: lying, sitting, sitting-to-standing, and standing | No special intervention | 3 months | ADLs: BI (0–100) (proportion of severity of disease: ≥ 3 and < 4; ≥ 4) Mean (SD) | 82.3 (21.3) | 76.7 (23.5) | 0.001 |
84.2 (21.9) | 79.9 (21.7) | 0.001 | |||||||
Function: Fugl–Meyer motor function assessment (0–100) (proportion of severity of disease: ≥ 3 and < 4; ≥ 4) Mean (SD) | 76.7 (23.5) | 58.7 (28.9) | 0.001 | ||||||
66.9 (25.4) | 57.6 (26.7) | 0.023 |
Author and year | Methods (country, design) | Participant: sample size, age (mean or mean and SD), female %, primary diagnosis (Dx) | Intervention (type, personnel, setting, brief description of intervention) | Comparison | Follow-up period | Outcomes and tools | Key findings | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pre-test | Post-test | p value | |||||||
Chinchai et al., 2021 | Thailand, pre- and post-test | N = 11 Age (range): 41–80 Female: 27% Dx: stroke | Rehabilitation education by VHWs in community rehabilitation centers Fundamental knowledge of stroke Mobility: physical exercise and gait training, UE function training ADL: selfcare, transfers, home chores | No control group | 2 months | Basic ADLs: the ADL assessment tool (BADL) (23–155) Mean (SD) | 67.41 (23.31) | 75.50 (21.17) | 0.026 |
Chinchai et al., 2020 | Thailand, pre- and post-test | N = 25 Age (range): 30–80 Female: 40% Dx: stroke | Rehabilitation education by VHWs in community rehabilitation centers Basic knowledge of stroke, mobility: exercise and gait, transfers, UE functional training ADL: dressing, grooming | No control group | 3 months | QOL: WHOQOL–BREF–THAI (0–100) Mean (SD) | 71.44(8.38) | 84.88(12.07) | 0.000 |
Community integration: CIQ (0–29) Mean [SD]) | 9.80 (3.96) | 11.44 (4.68) | 0.006 | ||||||
Chinchai et al., 2017 | Thailand, pre and post-test | N = 27 Age range: 30–80 Female: 37% Dx: stroke | Rehabilitation education by VHWs in patients’ homes Basic knowledge of stroke, mobility: gait training, balance, and UE and LE functional training | No control group | 2 months | Walking: 10-m walk test Mean (SD) | 34.73 (8.48) 0.17 m/s | 32.18 (9.32) 0.19 m/s | p < 0.05 |
UE function: FMA (0–44) Mean (SD) | 36.81 (9.59) | 37.26 (9.67) | 0.474 | ||||||
Balasubramanian et al., 2012 | India, comparative observational | N = 30 Age: IBR 37 (18.13), CBR 54 (13.55) Dx: locomotor disabilities | IBR by healthcare professionals* | CBR by CBR workers | Not describeda | Function: FIM (18–126) Mean (SD) | IBR: 117.40 (3.04) | CBR: 111.60 (12.02) | > 0.05 |
QOL: WHOQOL–BREF: (1–5) Mean (SD | IBR: 4.20 (0.414) | CBR: 4.00 (1.604) | > 0.05 |